Friday, April 28, 2006

The GRAND Viva

Every year this is a ritual that most professors in the department look forward to and students just want to get over with !!! For starters, this is THE grand viva where a panel of professors quizzes you on how good an engineer are you. What happens in the viva is almost a sadistic pleasure for profs and a lifetime experience for the student.

It so happened that our GV was scheduled for April 21. SO we just asked Prof. SC about how to study for GV. "Ohhh GV.....well my advice to you guys is not to study at all. You see the whole purpose of GV is to make you realise that you know nothing of chemical engineering and your degree is just an act of charity on the part of department ! " That said it all. Everyone looked at one another and laughed. Peace !! ...thats what i thought. I remembered an old advice "When you know you are gonna be f***ed and you can't help it then just lie down and enjoy !!". I smiled knowing that my limited knowledge would not be able to sustain the question profs will unfurl. It was a matter of how long rather than Can I .

The D-Day

A day before, someone leaked the panels....supposedly S ganguly and Gargi Das, two of the most dreaded profs were in my panel. I spent the entire day revising their course fully knowing it wouldn't help but just in case :D. When the panels are actually disclosed, I find that they are not in my panel. Ohh s**t !! Thats what everyone said beacause all our preparations were thrown haywire. Anyway by then most of us had resigned to fate and were just waiting for the gang rape to begin !! Everyone coming out of the room had a dejected look and a "Raped-i-knew-nothing" look on their faces. It was my turn next and I go in to face DD Kar(DDK), Kundu(GK), Neogi(SN) and JK Basu(JKB).

DDK: Suryansh, bolt the door.
ME: Yes Sir( Ohh no I can't even leave !!)
DDK: So what is equivalent diameter.
Me: Told hydraulic radius (I thought they were same)

For the next 3 mins. he made me realise that i am a duffer not to know this

DDK: Have you heard of FCC ?
Me: Yes Sir
DDK: Where ?
Me: Refineries for cracking(My first answer , cheers ! !)
DDK: Whats the difference between Packed Bed and FCC ?
Me: Blah blahed something
DDK: Thats the definition not difference. Ok tell me where is the pressure drop higher ?
Me: Packed Bed( took a guess)
DDK: Wrong !! If you don't know say I don't know , don't bluff.
Me: Ok, Sir

Next few questions:

What's Stefan-boltzamnn's constant ?
Whats emmissivity , absorptivity et al ?
Whats black body and grey body ?
How does heat transfer take place in a heated ball ?

Answered some haf-convincingly.

JKB: Ok how will you get a methyl ethyl ketone
Me: (Shit learnt the rxns. during JEE days..abhi yaad nahin aa raha) Sir oxidise aldehyde
JKB: Wrong, you oxidise a secondary alcohol. What catalyst do you use ?
Me:(What crap...I know of only 1 catalyst thats vanadium pentaoxide) V2O5
JKB: Wrong...alumina

The next few questions were on the catalysts used in different reactions. My answer was the standard...V2O5 :D.

JKB: Do u know any other catalyst ?
Me: Yes Sir...Alumina
JKB: Yeah, u just heard that(snigger).....Do u know whats a secondary alcohol ?
Me: Yes Sir(Ofcourse...I am not that duffer)
JKB: Thank god you know something
Me: GRIN

GK: What is Flash Point
Me: (Ahhh...that i know) said
GK: Thats how a layman defines it....talk like a chemical engineer
Me: (I thought I knew this one.....how else do I say that !@#$) Sir thats all I know
GK: Will it be same in kharagpur and delhi ?
Me: No Sir(obviously otherwise u wouldn't have aksed me the question)
GK: So what does it depend on ?
Me: Sir, oxygen content
GK: Thats as obvious as saying you are a boy !!
Me: *GRIN*
GK: If we increase the oxygen content then...
Me: Blah Blahed...
GK: Come on, I have given you enough clues....tell me the factors. Ok if we increase the oxygen content but the air content remains same
Me: (It must be vapour pressure thats y he is asking me this)...Sir, VP
GK/SN: So now u get to the point.....tahnksfullly !!

SN(twirling the lat remains of the hairs on his head): Ok I will ask a simple question
Me: (Abhi tak sab simple hi pooch rahe the..tu bhi pooch le)
SN: Whats the difference between equilibrium and steady state?
Me: Blah Blahed something.......
SN: Steady state i get but equilibrium u have not defined properly
Me:(Abe define kiya na...itna bahut hai....zyaada mat chaato)
The discussion meanders on to Le-Chatelier principle and chemical potential and activity but Neogi is still stuck on equilibrium.
SN: You still haven't defined equilibrium
Me:(!@#$) Sir I know only this much
SN: Ok

DDK: What is flooding and loading ?
Me: (Arey haan...II yr. ki lab main kuch kuch kiya tha...fortunately I recollect the graph)I draw a graph
DDK: Whats this ? Explain .
Me: Blah Blahed....
All professors start chuckling

(Saala main yahan kuch bata raha hoon aur tum logon ko hansi aa rahi hai !!)

GK: Do you want a RE?
ME: No SIr( Bas please pass kar do !!)

DDK: You may go now !!
Me: Thank you Sirs (What a relief !!)

That was my great great GV. By the end I had blah blahed so much that even i forgot what I was talking !! Hopefully I won't have to do an encore. Amen to that ;) !!

Monday, April 17, 2006

Monday, April 10, 2006

I feel the best when...

I feel the best when....

  • I put my head on my mom's lap and she gently caresses my hair and kisses my forehead
  • I am sad and Papa says "Pareshan kyun hote ho? Hum log hain na. "
  • I visit my old school and get recognised
  • I meet my old friends and we share a hearty laugh
  • I manage a bike and zip-off with absolutely no concerns about anyone
  • I manage a tricky problem after a lot of struggle
  • I go on a trip with my family
  • I am watching a movie after a tough exam
  • My niece looks innocently at me and says "Koi complaint hai ?"
  • On Diwali, the entire joint family gets together and bursts carackers
  • Me and didi give Papa/Mummy a surprise on their anniversary
  • I am chatting with friends
  • Someone ;) used to call me up until an year back
  • I am lazing away at home
  • I stretch my niece's chubby cheek and she gives me "Touch me not" stare
  • I am alone on a beach remembering the good 'ol days
  • My crazy wingies pull it up on someone, ofcourse not me ;)
  • In winters, all of my family snuggles into quilts and mummy serves hot coffee
  • I catch up with cousins and we recreate the bachpan ki masti
  • I get to watch a cricket match(where India has a chance to win) with no work pending
  • I travel to new places.....I love tarvelling

Mandal Era Revisited

Just when everyone was raving about the bumper placements in IITs and Indian B-schools, Arjun Singh decides to drop a bombshell and take reservations in centrally funded institutes upto 50%. A heated debate is going on all over the country and certainly this is one topic that deserves all the attention it is getting. And this is also one issue I feel very strongly about.

The Problem

As of now, the reservation in top institutes like IITs and IIMs stands at 15% for SC and 7.5% for ST. With 27% more being reserved for OBC, general category students get only 50.5% of seats. Given the tough competition already for he seats in these premier colleges, naturally the people are disgusted at this unwanted gesture. It only gets harder to get in. Reservation exist in other central universities also but people hardly care about them. The fuss is about IIT/IIM because these institutes are known to provide middle class guys the platform to launch a decent career.

Reservation are unfair

In my opinion, resevations are grossly unfair to students. As I often say, the law makers of the country are a myopic lot. Their decisions are mostly based on short term and bloody political gains. None of them has the vision and guts to take a call on matters of national importance. The fact that a well educated man like Manmohan Singh is at the helm of the affairs and behind this decision only makes things worse. If this act gets passed, one thing is sure- I shall never vote for Congress.Not that I xpected much from Sonia Gandhi and her Congress but now even the last straw has been pulled. For that matter, all political parties have in-turn ang-raped the educational abric of India.

Coming back to he main premise, Arjun Singh says that these reservations are meant to give the people of backward castes a fair chance to compete with other students. Something to ensure social equality. Ahem, haven't we heard that often ? What about economic equality Sir ? For the sake of analysis, let us divide the entire population into 4 subsects:
1. High Social Status, High Economic Status
2. High Social Status, Low Economic Status
3. Low Social Status, High Economic Status
4. Low Social Status, Low Economic Status

As per the current rules, Class 1 does not get any reservation and they need not get so. And Class 4 gets reservation and deservedly so. No arguements there. The bone of contention is between Classes 2 & 3 and wheher Class 4 is actually able to utilise the available reservations for its upliftment. Most middle class families fall under Class 2. Government feels that they do not deserve reseravtions while Class 3 does. When Ambedkar envisaged reservations in the first place, he said that they ought to be done for a fixed time frame to correct the wrongs done to these people and help them get to mainstream life. However, political parties have since then used this as a political tool and what was intended to bridge the social divide has become the biggest divisor. Two wrongs never make a right. If the wrongs done to these castes have to be addressed then they have to be done at the basic levels. A good institution cannot correct 12 years of poor education no matter how hard you try. Institutes like IIT/IIM have a reputation that has been developed over years by the distinguished quality of its students and faculty. The success of these lay in meritocracy. Quotas will hit this very foundation of theirs and soon these like many good things in our country will deteriorate thanks to our politicians.

Just imagine a scenario. You are going to give the exam that will in all probability shape your destiny. It is an exam where just 1 bloody mark can make or break you career. For each single seat, the fight is just too much and whn you realise that some person who just about managed to pass his XII gets the seat you wanted because his certificate had that "SC/ST/OBC" writen on it. It doesn't matter whether you worked your guts out and he did not. Your birth certificate just wasn't good enough. How frustrated would that guy be.

Fallacies:

Even the visionary Baba Ambedkar proposed a 10% reservation for 10 years. More than fifty years hence, the quotas still stand at 50%. Doesn't it look like a cover-up for the inefficiencies of government, mostly of Congress, over the past half-a-millenium. I definitely think so. The Congress governments and some of other parties have utterly failed to provide social justice and to make up for that, they decide to penalise students. Has anyone kept track of how many families have benefitted from reservation ? Does anyone know of any Class 4 family that has been able to improve its status after availing of reservation ? The government has no data. It just acts on political whims and fancies.

As a matter of fact, a paper published by a JNU professor, Dr. Pradipta Chaudhary, has some interesting observations:

With respect to literacy rate, three OBCs, namely, Sonar, Halwai and Kalwar, were ahead of four high castes, namely, Rajput, Taga, Bhat and Kandu. Similarly, with respect to economic status, five OBCs, namely, Sonar, Jat, Gujar, Kisan and Mali, were better off than Brahman and Rajput, the two most numerous high castes, which accounted for one-fifth of the Hindu population. Two SCs, namely, Khatik and Dusadh, had higher literacy rates than many OBCs.

He concludes:

Even in a backward region like U.P. at the beginning of the 20th century, there were large variations in the literacy rates and economic conditions of castes that were later pooled together and treated as homogeneous categories...High ritual rank could not secure some of the upper castes against low economic status. Similarly, low ritual status did not prevent large sections of Jat, Gujar, Sonar, Kisan and Mali from attaining prosperity. Caste did not preclude the upward economic mobility of a section of the untouchables. Even with ‘5000 years old tradition of learning’, the Brahman population of U.P. could not reach an average of 12% literacy by 1911; they were not the most literate of castes.

As Dr. Indiresan, a former IIT M director puts it " The average family income of SC/ST students is twice that of General category students". Its only the cremy layer that avails of the quotas and not the economically backward people. Therein lies the death of purpose.

The Fallouts

The implications of such a faulty policy can be severe. As of now, the cut-off marks for general category students are 30 and that for SC/ST students are 10. If more quotas are enforced, then this cut-off wil drop further and then the quality automatically suffers. IITs and IIMs are not acclaimed for their research or infrastucture but for the quality of its students and faculty that can compete with the very best. If there can be quotas for students in IIT then it logically follows for teachers as well and then the entire educational structure will come crumbling down. Besides, its not just about getting in but keeping pace with the competition once you come in. The academic standards will have to be brought down to accommodate these students who are not so industrious. Agreed some OBC students do make it through General category but they are less in number and it is likely that they too will take it easy when quotas are enforced.

These reservations have the potential of creating a caste system within these institutes. Right now, there is perfect harmony and accord between students but once the quotas come in place, then 'groupism' is likely to surface again. In many government colleges where there are reservation for OBCs, there are student groups of Rajputs, OBCs, SC/STs and the likes. These groups socialise only among themselves and clashes between groups are very frequent. This fanaticism will also make way into these elite institutions. And ofcourse, Arjun Singh and the PM are blissfully unaware of this.

Even the companies that come to campus may begin to distinguish between studnets on the basis of caste. It is quite possible that seeing the quality of students that come through quotas, companies shortlist only students of General category. Those companies are not bound to take students if they find them unworthy of their standards. What happens then ? Why doesn't the government propose a reservation in Union Cabinet as well ? Theywon't simplu because it hurts their vested interests. The children of minisers and the likes have never gone through the grind of preparing for a competitive examination so it is unlikely that the law makers know the kind of injustice they are doing. For them, its nothing but politics but for some, it can change their lives for the worse.

This can also open the flood gates for Brain Drain. People reasonably talented and with enough money will certainly decide to pursue studies abroad rather than study in a phony institute in India. Over the years, a reverse brain drain was happening but with this move, I guess the menace of brain drain will resurface and this time the exodus will be highe both in quality and quantity.

Alternate policy


In today's world, especially in Metros and cities, your caste doesn't determine how you live but your bank balance does. People would be more than willing to shake hands with a chamar company executive rather than that of a destitute brahman . Your money decides your social status and the facilities you get. Reservation on a financial basis makes much more sense and is more socially justifiable. People may argue that fake income certificates are easy to procure but then only people with business in remote areas and farmers can do so. These people even if financially sound are not able to avail of the best of opportunities in most cases. So even if they get some favour it is not as grave an injustice. Certainly the kids of OBC ministers do not deserve reservation. Economic backwardness is a necessary and sufficient criteria for reservation. More importantly, the government needs to come up with a regular appraisal of setas utilised by reservations. I think no more than two generation of SC/ST families should have the benefit of reservation.

Reseravtions can never be a solution for social inequality but meritocracy sure can be !!

Thursday, April 06, 2006

Media - Watchdog or Lapdog

Aamir Khan gave a rare candid interview to Tehelka recently. He talks about is grudges with media and I seem to agree with most of them. The media needs some check on the way it covers events which at most times is bizarre and irresponsible. Here are some points quoted verbatim from tehelka:

" No, as I said, there are various reasons. Along with this, in the last one year or so, I’ve been amazed at the kind of reporting that’s happening in national news — whether it’s television or print. It’s extremely disturbing, I find. Strange and unimportant stories are constantly making headlines. Only things which are sensational or cater to very base emotions of people are headline news. I realise TV channels are sprouting every day and there’s a lot of competition to grab viewership. Similarly with newspapers. As a result they are stooping to the lowest levels to try and get readership or viewership which actually translates into money. So at the end of the day because they want more ads they are destroying what is a very important part of society and that is news reporting. The nation and society at large have a right to know what is happening in the country and in the right manner and right perspective. The kind of news making headlines today — earlier they used to be tidbits or one page which was meant to be entertaining, or half a page — not even one page. But now that’s the main news and stories of farmers dying or something equally important that affects our lives or affects the lives of a lot of people are being pushed to small, unimportant sections of the paper. I find this very damaging and alarming.

Some ig somewhere has become Radha and that is national news, some actress has lost her dog, somebody’s affair has broken up, somebody’s in hospital — all personal stuff — and that’s national news. Certainly people would be interested in the film industry or entertainment world but that should not get the kind of prominence it is getting, I feel. It’s wasting important national space that should be used in a more productive manner.

This was immediately followed by a very personal event in my life which was my marriage and in which I again felt the press had gone completely nuts (laughing) — in the way they were trying to exploit that occasion for their financial benefit. Trying to get pictures, going to lengths where they were making up what we were supposed to be wearing or what my children were supposed to have reacted to or said… All kinds of things. Absolute imagination.

The thing is, I feel before being a star I am a human being and I have the right to conduct my life the way I want to, especially my personal life. If I’m getting married and I want to share it with a few close people, I feel I should be left alone to do that. Yes, report that I’m getting married, but that just makes one news item. I don’t think it deserves the kind of space it got in national news."



"
Newspapers like The Times of India were printing false news about me during the marriage. This is supposed to be one of the most prestigious newspapers in the country. None of the others are far behind. All the leading newspapers today are only interested in printing photographs of naked women in at least five pages of the publication — that’s what it’s come down to as far as I can see — on a daily basis (laughing) — not a one-off, on a daily basis."



"
Obviously they have to be governed by public interest. But stories like the India TV sting about starlets and the casting couch — first of all, that’s not of national interest. Secondly, if at all such a story is to be done the woman must look like she doesn’t want to sleep with the man and is being coerced in some way. In this, as far as one could make out the journalist was almost seducing him."



"
See filmmakers are still entertaining (laughs), the press has got a much more responsible job. Some restraint you have to show, boss. Yes, human beings have all kinds of needs. I can name another ten you can cater to — you want to do that? Are you a newspaper? Or stop calling yourself a newspaper. Stop calling yourself a news channel. Call yourself something else. There are all kinds of entertainment going around. You can certainly indulge in whatever kind of software you want to make. But if you are catering to the news needs of people then you call yourself a newspaper or news channel. If you are catering to other needs then don’t call yourself that."



"
There are so many. The Hindustan Times twice printed the completely false news that that I was married to Preity Zinta! There were three or four interviews that I had not given that came out in Asian Age! Channel 7 once telecast an interview with me that was not with me at all. This was around the time that the Salman Khan tapes had been made public. Some channel asked me to react. I gave a live byte on air. Suddenly my sister called from Bangalore saying, are you talking to Channel 7 because they have a picture of you doing a telephonic interview but it’s not your voice. I’m your sister, I know. I had done no telephonic interview so there was an interview going on with someone who claimed he was Aamir Khan!

During the Bombay floods, the first time it was pretty bad. But a few days later there was rain again. Now, I live in Bombay, the second time it rained there wasn’t that kind of floods. I drove my car along the highway and I went to various places and in fact Bombay was not locked on that day. But the national news was propagating that it was. And they were showing footage of the earlier flood and not even calling it file footage.

Again, I met this guy at a Rang De party. I had no idea who he was. He said he was from Mumbai Mirror and asked for an interview. I said, I don’t give interviews. To which he said, why? I may have said one or two lines about why I don’t talk to the press. Next you know that had become an exclusive interview in Mumbai Mirror, and I think Delhi Times reproduced it! Another glaring example of the media crossing limits was when Mr Bachchan fell ill. I think it could even have been dangerous as far as his health was concerned. Abhishek was mentioning to me how he had trouble even getting him into the hospital!"

For the full text, click here.

Even in the recent LFW dress malfunctions, there was no dire need of giving it so much airtime. It was a huge embarassment for the models and there was no need to let their embarassment be broadcast directly to every other person who might not be interested in watching that. It is more traumatic for the persons involved and in my view, it is not a news item but just titillation.

One reason why this is happening is because the news channels now run 24 hours which means that they need constant flow of new information. The easiest way out is to show the already recorded ones over and over again even though they do not deserve more than a mention. Even more so, LFW malfunctions are breaking news !! Utter Crap..

I couldn't agree less with what Ammir Khan said and i thin it is high time that there is some code of conduct for media otherwise the problem will get increasingly menacing.

Wednesday, April 05, 2006

My Wingies

My stay in IIT would not have been so eventful had it not been for this bunch of crazy and weird ppl. Hence, it is only appropriate that they get their place of honour on my blog. Here are some shining examples of our joblessness and I am looking very grumpy in this :D






Btw Anish"Thanaa", the Public affairs,Science and Technology minister has made a nice compilation of the crazy things we have done in the wing.