Ahoy Dada !!
Being an avid sports afficionado who reads the sports page of the newspaper more ardently than any of the course-books, I had to comment on the latest hot topic. No prizes for guessing this one - Saurav Ganguly !! Well, India is a nation where emotions in cricket run fever pitch and the constant media scrutiny only adds fuel to the fire. The fact that this issue has come up in Parliament (though undeserving to be discussed on that platform) shows that a lot of feathers have been ruffled. I have been associated with bengal for the past four years but thankfully none of the bengali chauvinism has rubbed off on me. Here is my take on the issue.
The Controversy
Chief selector Mr. Kiran More says that they are looking towards the 'future' and are not intent on 'looking backwards'. A politically correct statement that conveyed its meaning when read between the lines. 'Endulkar' was the press talk after the indo-pak test series but now we would rather have 'Enguly'. Leaving out a player of the stature of Ganguly for young blood is a huge risk. If the young guns don't perform, selectors would be on trial and if they succeed, it will be even more difficult for ganguly to come in. The problem is that in Indian cricket, which has often relied on individuals and past records such a decision is very bizarre. The question is whether it reflects the positive thinking of selectors or their bias.
The Replacements
Giving the logic of selecting a team for world cup, selectors have given Ganguly the boot and instead showed faith in Kaif and Raina, two UP youngsters.
Talking about the test side, let me admit that ganguly was not a great test player. He had a good average but failed to play any long significant innings of note even in his prime. Part of it can be blamed on the fact that he came lower down the order . But Gilchrist, another south-paw comes even lower but has had more impact than ganguly. Earlier Ganguly held on to his place by virtue of being captain and the fact that there was no suitable replacement. Now that Ganguly is not the captain and Yuvraj is firing all cylinders, it was anybody's guess who was going to be in the team. But with Yuvraj missing, Ganguly should have got his rightful place. Kaif, whose form is often like a sinusoidal wave, is tipped to take his place. With all due respect to the talent of kaif, i beg to differ that he does not merit a place in the test team, especially not on the expense of Ganguly. For the record, Kaif has a batting average of just 22 in 8 tests with just 2 fifties. Even his highest first class score is 136. Certainly not the makings of a good test player. It would have been better for him and india had he come into the team after playing a year or two in the Ranji league. The problem with early induction into the team is that if you can't stand the trial by fire, you are doomed. Same thing happened with Parthiv patel and now he seems to have been forgotten in the Dhoni blitz. One arguement given favour of Kaif is fielding but then Ganguly is also a better bowler than Kaif though Ganguly's bowling exploits in the tests are not as impressive as in ODIs. Nonetheless, he can bowl and definitely on current form, he would have contributed as a batsman as well. Not to forget, his experience in international arena. My point is that in Dravid, Tendulkar, Laxman, Yuvraj and Ganguly , India now have 5 middle order batsman and the best four on form and fitness should select themselves. Age or young blood should not be the decisive criteria for selection. After all, McGrath and Warne are still th leading lights in Aussie teams despite the ageing concerns. I don't understand the problem with Ganguly being in the team and not playing. On one hand, Dravid talks of work ethics and professionalism and on the other hand he says that if dada is in the team, he will have to play. Its high time to set some standards in team meritocracy. No player is larger than the team even if it is Tendulkar or Dravid. Why should their selection be automatic if they are not in the best of forms while the others are ? For India, it should be a happy problem.
Coming to the one-dayers, it is here that dada walks in as a goliath with over 10000 runs under his belt. His current form is a cause of concern but if the talk is about a team for world cup then he has to be in. Kaif is a brilliant fielder, no doubt but you just can't walk into a team just beacuse of fielding unless you are a Jonty Rhodes. Even Rhodes was a handy batsman. The World Cup will be in west indies which is known for its seaming pitches. Ganguly can be handful in those conditions. Already India are a bowler short and in west indies, the bowlers will win matches and not batsmen. Besides, if Ganguly is susceptible to the short ball then Kaif too is to the ball moving away. Kaif has had many chances in one-dayers and his one-day form outside the sub-continent isn't great with an average in early 20s. His last noteworthy contribution overseas (barring minnows) was in the Natwest Challenger against england in 2004 when he made 51. Certainly dada is not worse than him. He is not the most feared striker either as his strike rate suggests. He is a grafter. He does save a lot of runs through his fielding but in West Indies you will need a batsman who can bowl military medium. If fielding is the criteria then Raina should also get a look-in. Besides, Ganguly does not drop catches. His ground fielding is a bit shoddy though. My point is that earlier Dada used to be an automatic selection but on present form, he does make the cut though not so convincingly.
Selectors- Pack of Jokers
Mohinder Amarnath could not have found a more apt phrase to describe the selectors. While selecting the team for 2003 world cup they picked Mongia ahead of Laxman because they thought that Mongia could bowl spin and fielded well. Laxman, an artistic accumulator, was ignored. After the world cup they were definitely embarassed at their choice. This time too the selectors seem to have not learnt their lesson. The team needs to be picked considering where it is playing and its requirements. They need batsman to counter the movement and a handful of medium pace bowlers. Ganguly will be of greater utility than Kaif or Raina, the fielding not withstanding. Buoyed by team's success, the selectors are making a shabby atempt to copy their Australian counterparts. The team needs a blend of youth and experience and all players in the team come after a good stint in the first class matches. Not like in India when you perform in under-19 and you make the cut. Sometimes such experiments succeed but that should be the exception rather than the rule. You have to give players time to mature. Yuvraj took 5 years to mature now. The case of Parthiv Patel is for all of us to see. Kaif too seems to be going that way. As for Irfan Pathan we will have to wait and watch but so far so good. The selectors should have dropped Ganguly earlier when we was so woefully out of form but they persisited with him then. And now when he looks like he has regained his touch then they drop him. I seriously do not get the logic. Two wrongs never make a right !! And if the selectors have decided that its the end of the road for Ganguly and nothing can change their bias then they should tell Ganguly so. For a player who has given Indian Cricket so much he certainly deserves a hero's farewell rather than the ignominy of an unwanted. May be the selectors can take a leaf out of their australian counterparts here who let Steve Waugh retire the way he wanted !!!